A hypothesis about the strange Left-Islamist alliance — both of them marching together to support Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Ayatollahs, and both hostile to USA, Israel, the West more broadly.
Drawing upon two perceptive analysts, Friedrich Nietzsche and John Stuart Mill:
* Nietzsche in 1887: “the truly great haters in world history have always been priests.”
* Mill in 1879: “the animating principle of too many of the revolutionary socialists is hate.”
Hatred is the common demonimator. To update from then to now, for the type of “priests” Nietzsche had in mind, substitute today’s jihadi mindset coming out of politicized Islam. And for the “revolutionary socialists” Mill had in mind, substitute today’s woke-Antifa mindset coming out of poisoned academia.
So a psychological explanation for the odd activist alliance. Islamists and Wokists despise each other’s official beliefs, but their emotional set is the same, which unites them against the hated enemy.
Sources: From the First Essay, Section 7 of Nietzsche’s Genealogy of Morals, introducing his ressentiment analysis. From p. 430 of the collected Principles of Political Economy and Chapters on Socialism, wherein Mill discusses those socialists who are less interested in improvement than in raging against the current system.
Related: The classically and Western-educated Qutb’s call to jihaad. In my Philosophers, Explained series.
The first essay of Nietzsche’s Genealogy of Morals:
i think it would serve to have a date on the posts .
also i cant find the one where we debated [christianity]
Reply
i did find it. praise God
I just refused to move in with granma and risk losing my job .. connectivity and all .
and I am still losing my job . nice way to know I made the wrong choice. God is good, I hear his will.
Reply