Pleased to see that this debate has over 60,000 views at YouTube alone. The New York event was fun and instructive. During the debate, Thaddeus Russell and I differed sharply over how skeptical the leading postmodernists and their forerunners were. So in addition to quoting them directly, I offered to post the sources for them. Here again is the link to my quotes from Ayer, Schlick, Quine, Feyerabend, Kuhn, and Lentrichhia. They really said that, they really mean it, and their activist followers do too.
Also: The debate results are posted here.