Stephen Hicks, Ph.D.

Philosopher

Plato on censoring artists — a summary

In my Philosophy of Art course, we are discussing Plato’s philosophy of art, by means of selections from Statesman and Books 3 greek-msand 10 of The Republic, along with snippets from Ion, Phaedrus, and Symposium.

In The Republic, Plato makes a systematic case for censoring all arts. The task of the Platonic philosopher is to take up the “ancient quarrel between philosophy and poetry” [607b] and to assert the State-enforced dominance of philosophy. To that end, The Republic as a whole is a powerful integration of philosophy, religion, education, and politics, and its argument for the political suppression of most art follows from that integrated system.

Rhetorically, Plato uses Socrates’ discussion with Glaucon and Adeimantus to list a series of grievances against poetry, music, and painting:

hesiod* A good portrait of the gods and heroes will show them as worthy and exalted beings — but poets such as Homer and Hesiod often tell tales of the gods and heroes fighting and bickering and acting immorally [e.g., 390b-391e].

* A moral citizen’s soul will be composed and dignified — but many musical modes stir us up inside and make us jangled and unsettled [398e-400d.].

* Good people and gods do not deceive — but painters constantly deceive us by trying to make their fake imitations look real [598c, 602d]. (Meanwhile, Plato allows that politicians (and only politicians) ought to be allowed to lie to their citizens [389b-c].)

* A strong and moral man will not grieve the death of a friend by moaning and wailing like a woman — but poets regularly have their characters issue long, pathetic lamentations [387d-388d].

achilles* Courageous men are willing to die in battle — but the poets tell scary stories about the afterlife and make us fear death [386b-d].

* A proper moral of the story will teach that good people meet good ends and bad men meet bad ends [613d-614a] — but tragic poets have will often have bad men profit and protagonists fail and suffer despite their virtues [392b].

* Decent people respect and strive for worthiness — but comic poets appeal to our basest desires and mock and deride everything [e.g., 395d-e, 606c].

And so on.

The Republic’s overall argument for censorship thus combines a particular conception of morality with religion and authoritarian politics. Formalizing the argument:

1. To have a good society, we must have good citizens.
2. To have good citizens, children must be well educated.
plato3. To be well educated, children must be exposed to good material and shielded from bad material [386a].
4. So, to have a good society, children must be exposed to good material and shielded from bad material.
5. It is the obligation of the State to educate its citizens.
6. So the State should allow only good material and suppress bad material.
7. The State’s censorship applies also to art.
8. So the State should allow only good art and suppress bad art [401b, 595a].

[Next: Evaluating Plato's argument for censoring the arts. Return to the Intellectual History page.]

Posted 2 weeks ago at 8:46 am.

1 comment

Profiles in Liberty: Douglas B. Rasmussen

rasmussen-banner3

In this extended interview, philosopher Douglas B. Rasmussen responds to a series of questions (listed below) about his life and work.

Dr. Rasmussen is a professor of philosophy at St. John’s University in New York. In addition to the books discussed in the interview, he is the author of articles in American Philosophical Quarterly, The Review of Metaphysics, International Philosophical Quarterly, and many scholarly anthologies.

questions1Why did you become a philosopher? [00:18]
Where did you go to college? [1:02]
Why does liberal society need a philosophical basis? [1:17 ]
You present those themes in some detail in your books Liberty and Nature, Liberalism Defended, and Norms of Liberty. What is your argument for liberty? [2:44]
questions2Previous question continued [00:09]
Which historical philosophers have you learned most from? [6:08]
How do those issues of metaphysics connect to liberalism? [8:15]
Which major historical philosophers do you most disagree with? [11:28]
questions3What is the hardest philosophical problem you are working on now? [00:08]
What is the most challenging criticism of your views? [2:43]
What is the state of liberal thought today among philosophers? [4:36]
To bring about a more liberal society, what key practical steps can and should be taken? [6:30]

Coming Soon: Profiles in Liberty interview with economist David R. Henderson.

Related: Stephen Hicks interviews Douglas Rasmussen about Philippa Foot’s Natural Goodness.

Posted 2 weeks, 1 day ago at 8:23 am.

Add a comment

Rights in Mises, Hayek, and Rand — APEE panelists

Rights in Mises, Hayek, and Rand

I am chairing a session and presenting a paper on the theme of “Rights in Mises, Hayek, and Rand” for the annual conference of the Association for Private Enterprise Education, to be held April 1-3, 2012 in Las Vegas, Nevada.

miseshayekrand_50x66The rationale for the session: Three giants of twentieth-century thought — but few comparative studies have been done. The following panelists will discuss rights-related issues in the thought of Ludwig von Mises, Friedrich Hayek, and Ayn Rand.

Richard Ebeling, Department of Economics, Northwood University
Title: Mises on Rights and Principles

Eric Mack, Department of Philosophy, Tulane University
Title: Desert and Entitlement in Atlas Shrugged

Michelle Vachris, Department of Economics, Christopher Newport University
Title: Atlas Shrugged down The Road to Serfdom: Rand and Hayek on Rights

Stephen Hicks, Department of Philosophy, Rockford College
Title: Economic facts and values in Mises, Hayek, and Rand

Posted 2 weeks, 2 days ago at 4:39 pm.

Add a comment

Full interview with fashion-design entrepreneur Chan Luu

My full interview with Chan Luu is now posted at the Center for Ethics and Entrepreneurship’s site.

k19-cover-250-pxChan Luu’s designs have been worn by many celebrities, including Jennifer Lopez, Lady Gaga, Kate Hudson, Reese Witherspoon, Sandra Bullock, Janet Jackson, and Jennifer Aniston. Much of the interview was published last month in Kaizen. I met with Luu in Los Angeles to discuss growing up in Vietnam, the relevance of business education to entrepreneurial success, and the complexities of doing business in the fast-changing world of celebrities and fashion.

More Kaizen interviews with leading entrepreneurs are at my site here or CEE’s site.

Posted 2 weeks, 4 days ago at 1:08 pm.

Add a comment

Employment in agriculture: statistics

agricultureShare of US labor force working in agriculture:

1840: 64%
1880: 43%
1920: 27%
1960: 10%
2000: 1.5%

What an amazing transformation over 160 years.

Interesting to compare the USA’s numbers with these statistics from the CIA’s World Factbook on percentages of people employed in agriculture around the world, e.g., Afghanistan 78%, Kyrgyzstan 48%, Malaysia 13%, New Zealand 7%, Singapore 0.1%.

Posted 3 weeks, 1 day ago at 4:34 pm.

1 comment

Philosophy of Art — syllabus and schedule

michelangelo-1511Here is the syllabus and schedule [pdf] for my Spring 2012 Philosophy of Art course.

More information about this and my other courses at the Courses page.

Posted 3 weeks, 3 days ago at 1:09 pm.

Add a comment

Philosophical Foundations of Education — syllabus and schedule

pencils-150x100Here are the syllabus and schedule [pdf] for my Spring 2012 Philosophical Foundations of Education course.

More information at the Courses page.

See also my 48-hour Philosophy of Education lecture series on video, available free online.

Some related posts on education:

Locke versus Kant on motivation and discipline
Geniuses and their followers
Mathematics education
Adam Smith on accountability in education
Fichte on education as socialization
Dewey on education as socialization
Education and the National Socialists
Video interview with Jerry Kirkpatrick on Montessori and Dewey
How great artists become great
Sidney Hook on public education in New York in the early 1900s
Don’t know much about history — an anecdote
Women’s and men’s college graduation rates
Sir Ken Robinson on factory schools
Immigrant culture, race, and education
A complete listing of my education-related posts.

Posted 3 weeks, 4 days ago at 4:44 pm.

Add a comment

Business and Economic Ethics — syllabus and schedule

econhistthumbHere is the syllabus and schedule [pdf] for my Spring 2012 Business and Economic Ethics course. Core readings will be from the Concise Encyclopedia of Economics, Forbes Greatest Business Stories of All Time, Atlas Shrugged, and Kaizen.

More information at the Courses page. See also my Business and Economic Ethics page.

Posted 3 weeks, 4 days ago at 2:56 pm.

Add a comment