3 responses

  1. john t marohn
    August 22, 2009

    Thanks for the comments on the need for a “collective,” communal, extended family model in our culture.

    The rabid “rugged individualists” and Ayn Rand objectivists would have us all believe that, as individuals, we have no obligations to others except the “do ut des” agreements we make with each other.

    We are seeing this battle being played out in the national debate about health insurance. On the one hand, we have the rugged individualists who believe that the right to health insurance has to be earned in a job.

    Others, like myself, believe that every one should contribute to the general pot which we should draw from according to our needs and what we can individually afford to pay for in terms of premiums, deductables, and copays.

    Reply

  2. Stephen Hicks
    August 23, 2009

    John: Thanks for your post. A few quick questions for you.

    1. You say “every one should contribute to the general pot which we should draw.” Are you talking voluntary insurance or compulsory taxation? Big moral difference.

    2. You mention “the rugged individualists who believe that the right to health insurance has to be earned in a job.” I’ve never met or read anyone who believes this. Can you cite someone prominent who does?

    3. You write of “‘rugged individualists’ and Ayn Rand objectivists would have us all believe that, as individuals, we have no obligations to others except the “do ut des” agreements we make with each other.” Does this mean you think we have unchosen obligations to provide for others? And who should enforce those obligations? Forced, unchosen obligations to provide for others — does that sound a little like slavery to you?

    Reply

  3. Bob Marks
    August 24, 2009

    Hi John,

    You talk about filling the need for health insurance from the “general pot.” But there are other, more pressing needs, specifically food. After all, you may not need medical care for years, if you are lucky. But you need food every day. Should we also have the government take over food production to make sure we are all well fed?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop